It’s always helpful to know what to expect during the defense before heading into it. You may have specific questions, such as, How long is a dissertation defense? and, Will the defense be open to non-committee members?
It’s important to keep in mind that every university and program establishes its own rules, procedures and guidelines for a doctoral dissertation defense. The length of time for a defense that is typical for one school might not apply to another. Even within the same program, one defense may be longer than the next. Similarly, the exact protocols and procedures may vary a bit.
In general, however, a defense may use the following format:
- Presentation: The doctoral candidate will present their work, explaining their research topic, methodology, findings and analysis. It’s important to be clear and precise when explaining how you arrived at your conclusions given the research data you gathered.
- Questions and answers: After your presentation, you’ll have a question and answer session. Each member of the committee will ask you about your research, exploring the breadth of your knowledge. After the committee asks its questions, non-committee attendees may be invited to ask any questions of their own.
- Deliberation: Following the question and answer session, all non-committee members, including yourself, are typically asked to leave the room (real or virtual). (Sometimes, members of the public are asked to leave after the presentation.) The dissertation committee members then deliberate amongst themselves on whether or not to approve your dissertation and grant your degree. Then, you’ll be called back into the room to hear their decision.
It’s typically acceptable for the PhD candidate to invite their family members, friends and other supporters to the dissertation defense. The defense can be a proud moment in the candidate’s life, as it’s the culmination of all of their hard work and their chance to demonstrate their contributions to the field.